Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe

Bagel Island Coffee, located in the Big Pine Shopping Center, serves NY-style bagels made fresh daily alongside Cuban coffee, breakfast items, and deli sandwiches. Their menu features omelets, pastries, sandwiches, and flavorful options made with quality ingredients. Open mid-morning through early afternoon, it’s a favorite spot for locals and travelers in the Lower Keys. With warm service and a relaxed vibe, it’s an ideal stop for a satisfying breakfast or lunch.