Florida Keys Rental Store

The Florida Keys Rental Store is the residential property management division of American Caribbean Real Estate, an independent Upper Keys firm that has been in business since the 1980s and is the exclusive Florida Keys affiliate of Christie’s International Real Estate.

Its portfolio covers the Upper Keys, concentrated in Key Largo and Islamorada, and runs from waterfront pool homes through single-family houses to townhomes and condominiums. Short-term and seasonal rentals are both handled, so the same company can place a week in February or a month in the spring.

The business works from both sides. For visitors, staff match renters to the right property rather than leaving you to filter a list, and rental operations are staffed around the clock so a problem at nine at night reaches someone. For owners, the same division markets and maintains the properties it rents.

Being Upper Keys based has its advantages for a guest. Key Largo puts John Pennekamp Coral Reef State Park and most of the Keys’ dive operators within a few minutes, and Islamorada puts the backcountry flats, the Morada Way galleries and the restaurants along the Overseas Highway at the door.