Mattheessen's

With two locations on world-famous Duval Street, Mattheessen’s is a Key West staple for sweet tooth satisfaction. Known for their oversized cookies, creamy homemade ice cream, tangy key lime pie, and rich marble slab fudge, everything is made from scratch using only the finest ingredients. Whether you’re strolling Duval with family or hunting for the perfect late-night treat, Mattheessen’s delivers indulgence with a local twist.