Tiny's Bait
Tiny's Bait & Gas sits at 82788 Overseas Highway in Islamorada, around mile marker 82.8, on the stretch of US-1 that most Upper Keys fishing traffic drives past. It is a fuel station with a convenience store and a restroom, and the name leads with bait rather than gas for a reason.
The appeal for a visitor is the combination. Filling the truck, picking up bait and using a restroom in a single stop on the highway beats doing it in three, particularly at the hour when the ramp is already filling up. Call (305) 414-8346.