A Taste of Christmas: A Culinary Evening Inside The Oldest House
Thursday, December 10, 2026.
The Old Island Restoration Foundation opens the Oldest House after dark for a four-course dinner with wine pairings, prepared and served by Chef Juan Cuadra of Salty Chef. Seating is limited to ten guests at $200 per seat.
The setting is the point. The house at 322 Duval Street was built around 1829 by Richard Cussans, a Bahamian in his mid-twenties who came to Key West about 1826 and is believed to have trained as a ship’s carpenter. He framed it with mortise-and-tenon joinery pegged in wood rather than nailed, sheathed it in pine inside and out as a box within a box, and set it on stone piers. That construction is why it is still standing. When the Great Hurricane of 1846, now reckoned a category five, came through, every house in Key West but this one and seven others was destroyed or damaged. When the Great Fire of 1886 took fifty acres and more than five hundred downtown buildings, the Oldest House escaped. Generations of the Watlington family lived here, photographed together on the property around 1900.
Cuadra founded Salty Chef Catering in Key West and cooks privately in homes, on yachts and in vacation rentals. He is a Le Cordon Bleu graduate and a U.S. Marine with more than twenty years in luxury hospitality, including the Bellagio in Las Vegas, the Fairmont Turnberry Isle, and the mega-yachts Seafair and Vitesse. He has built VIP menus for the U.S. Open and The Masters, and his Nicaraguan background runs through his cooking. His pairing dinners elsewhere in Key West have covered bourbon, whiskey, rum, sake and wine.
Tickets are sold through the Foundation’s online box office. With ten seats, the evening is likely to sell before the date.