Abbondanza Italian Restaurant

Abbondanza Italian Restaurant has earned its reputation as Key West's favorite Italian dining spot the old-fashioned way — by consistently delivering great food, warm hospitality, and an atmosphere that feels like a neighborhood gem the moment you walk through the door. Nestled into three beautifully converted cigar-maker cottages in the heart of Old Town Key West, the restaurant's three intimate dining rooms are cozy, atmospheric, and perfectly Key West casual — no dress code, no pretense, just great Italian food and a genuinely good time. The menu is an Italian lover's dream, featuring classic pasta dishes like Fettuccine Alfredo al Funghi, Spaghetti Calabrese with spicy Italian sausage, Lasagna alla Bolognese, and Linguine Vongole, alongside fresh seafood specialties and appetizers like Burrata with Prosciutto de Parma and Fried Calamari, all paired with an extensive wine list and a bustling full liquor bar. Seating is first come, first served for most parties, with reservations available for larger groups — and with a 94% recommendation rate on Facebook and years of People's Choice Awards, you may want to arrive early and come with an appetite.